Shoreline Proposition 1: Is This the Right Time to Finance $100 Million for a Luxury Pool?
Thursday, October 1, 2026
Jeff Hays is part of the committee of three, chosen to write the Con statement for the voters pamphlet on Shoreline Prop 1
Many residents are rightfully questioning the creation of a new tax district and a permanent overall tax increase of 5.5% to 7.5% to finance $100 million in new debt for the construction and operation of a city-run pool. The City of Shoreline acknowledges that this initiative carries significant risks and yet placed the measure on the ballot anyway.
Financial and Taxpayer Risks
Interest-rate risk
Local and national news are dominated by concerns about rising interest rates and increasing debt costs. The City plans to issue bonds for pool construction in late 2027. If interest rates are higher than currently projected, the cost of servicing the debt over the next 20 years will increase dramatically. This could require the MPD to raise its tax rate beyond the initial proposed rate.
Rising property taxes and taxpayer fatigue
The proposition would add at least 33% to current city property taxes and increase total property taxes by approximately 5.5% to 7.5%. Property taxes in Shoreline have already increased much faster than inflation over the past eight years and are expected to continue rising.
Furthermore, the City is forecasting significant operating deficits by 2030. The City also plans to seek approval for another levy-lid lift (tax increase) in 2028—the same year the new MPD taxes would begin.
This raises an important question: Will the city be able to address its projected deficits, fund essential obligations, including sidewalks, public safety, existing park measures and successfully raise taxes further to pay for future public school projects?
Construction and Operating-Cost Risks
The $100 million construction estimate
The City’s current estimate for the pool is $100 million, or more than $1,500 for every Shoreline resident. However, the project is only approximately 10% designed. At this early stage, the cost estimate may not be sufficiently reliable. Continued inflation, changing construction costs, and design revisions could cause the final price to easily exceed $100 million. It is not too late to pause and find a viable solution that makes more sense.
Operating and maintenance costs
The City projects that operating and maintaining the pool will cost nearly $4.4 million annually on average during the first five years. If inflation or other factors push these costs above projections, the City may need to increase user fees, the MPD tax rate, or a combination of both.
Equity Concerns
The financial burden would not fall only on property owners. Those least able to absorb higher costs could be affected most severely. Property owners would pay the tax directly. Landlords will likely pass the increased cost on to renters through higher rent. Low-income seniors and people with disabilities will also be required to pay the new MPD taxes.
Some residents note that the new taxes could more than double what they currently pay in city taxes.
Other Aquatic Options
Shoreline residents currently have access to public pools in neighboring jurisdictions. The $100,000,000 question is: does the city of Shoreline need to be in the pool business? Edmonds, Lynnwood, Mountlake Terrace, and North Seattle all have viable options that charge daily access fees similar to those projected for the proposed Shoreline pool. Private options are also available, including the McMenamins Swimming Pool in Bothell and the Dale Turner YMCA.
These options allow Shoreline residents who want pool access to attain it for generally what it would cost them to do so with a new Shoreline pool, but without burdening all taxpayers with the proposed huge new tax obligation.
A Possible Public-Private Partnership
Alternatively, the City would be wise to further explore a public-private partnership with organizations like the YMCA, which have extensive experience developing and managing recreational facilities. Working with these organizations could include offering vouchers to aid in providing additional programming or staff support. Several Washington cities have successfully used public-private partnerships to provide recreation facilities while sharing development, operating, and financial responsibilities.
Conclusion
Everyone appreciates the value of added amenities and recreational facilities. This is not an argument against recreation or community pools; it is an argument for being fiscally responsible and keeping Shoreline affordable.
The City has more pressing priorities that should be addressed before taking on a new, long-term obligation. Proposition 1 involves substantial debt, uncertain interest and construction costs, ongoing operating expenses, and a permanent increase in property taxes. Sensible Shoreline voters should understand that Proposition 1 is too costly and financially risky at this time.
For more information, please visit our website at: shorelineprop1.com
-Shoreline Citizens for Responsible Spending.

10 comments:
This is well articulated. It's also worth mentioning a similar ballot proposition for ~$60MM failed several years ago.
Thank you for this well reasoned argument. Before voting I'd also suggest residents consider the city's ability to deliver on prior capital projects - for example the splash park at Hamlin park, which was approved in 2022 has now been under construction since March of 2025, with much work remaining. And on a more mundane level, the roundabout at the Shoreline N transit station, which was damaged in early 2025 has yet to be repaired due to (according to See-Click-Fix) a lack of funds and resources.
I get the concern about cost but I don’t think the value of a public pool should be measured only by whether every taxpayer personally uses it. Thats true of parks, libraries, playgrounds and plenty of other community amenities too. A public pool can serve seniors, adults exercising or doing rehab, lap swimmers, teens, families and people learning a basic life-safety skill. You don’t have to have kids to see the value in Shoreline having recreational infrastructure that makes it a stronger community
Thank you for this summation. As a low-income single parent with two children when I moved to Shoreline almost 30 years ago, the swimming pool was a lifeline for my two young boys and me. It was affordable recreation during all parts of the year. Many a gloomy winter evening we spent in warm water at the pool. I was and remain appreciative that the price we paid for admission was subsidized by my neighbors. Given that, I have debated long about voting for a new pool in Shoreline. The last time it was on the ballot I didn't vote either way as I felt I didn't have enough information, This time around, I will be voting no. If neighboring pools need to charge a higher rate for Shoreline residents, I support scholarships for our population that need them. And yes, I believe the city rushed to demolish the previous pool, and finding long range plan to remodel or rehabilitate it would have been prudent. My bottom line: this is not the time for the city to take on so much debt.
I am happy to put my name on my letter and am relieved someone out there is paying attention to this. I am frankly miffed that the city is asking it's residents to take on this financial burden at this time. The proponents are understandably excited about the architectural renderings and happy swimmers depicted on the " let shoreline swim" facebook site, looks great to me too ! On the other hand I don't think there is much critical thinking or regard for the long term financial burden this facility will impose on us. I will be voting no on this and hope everyone can get past the "woo-hoo" and look at the numbers. They definitely don't add up.
How do you spend $100 million on a pool complex? $16.6 million is to pay off the city's 2017 land purchase, leaving $83.4 million to build the pool complex. By comparison, Federal Way's Olympic-class aquatic center was built in 1990 at a cost of $18.8 million (per Wikipedia), with $8.8 million funded by King County and $5 million provided by the Goodwill Games Committee, on land donated by Weyerhaeuser Corp.; the Dale Turner YMCA with pool was built in 2008 for $19.5 million (presumably including land). Inflation alone can't explain the Shoreline proposal's much higher cost. This ballot proposition is reaching into our wallets for a gold-plater facility that, per the voters pamphlet, will add $421 a year to a median Shoreline home's property tax bill for the pool complex alone. Other facilities, such as a workout gym, would come later at additional cost. I'm not against paying a reasonable amount of tax for a facility built at reasonable cost, but this proposal needs to go back to the drawing board. Shoreline is asking for a Rolls Royce swimming complex; let's try something our city taxpayers can afford. I'm a "no" vote on this go-round.
The City of Shoreline needs to address other priorities, such as the aging Spartan Activity Center, Shoreline Senior Center, funding for Shoreline Police, etc. People wanting us to vote for Prop 1 pointed out that currently, Shoreline residents need to leave Shoreline to get to a public pool facility. We have been doing that for the last 6 years! Some of the Seattle Public Pools are really not that far away from Shoreline. Vote "Against" Prop 1.
Being a long time resident of Shoreline, i am mystified by the nerve of the City to ask for my approval of another taxing district with all sorts of taxing opportunities into the future, to build a 100 million swimming pool, to subsidize future ongoing operation and maintenance of the extremely expensive pool. It again shows the gulf between reality and political spectacle.
Shoreline property tax rate is approximately 1.10%, which is higher than the King County average of 0.83%. Do I want to pay more? No, not for this.
Shoreline has lost everything fun.
The Rat City Rollers were pushed out, the city pool was deemed too old, and we lost our skating rink for a vacant lot.
I see the political signs against this pool and it infuriates me. Everything does cost more now-I wonder why? Trump and war.
I know some people who are against this pool are all old people because I’m old and I still talk to them.
Baby boomers were given everything after World War II, they literally created suburbia for those babies. Now, that same generation just can’t pay it forward. They hold most of the wealth in this country and half of them vote Trump because they just want another tax cut.
On the math, the median is $400-600 bucks per household. Fine, let’s say it’s $1,500-$2000 bucks.
So today’s babies can’t learn a life skill? You farts don’t need rehab or old fart aerobics? Can’t you misers just do a good thing before you die a hypocritical hippy death?
Your generation sucks and I know, because I had to grow up with you all as a Gen X’er.
Just pass this thing and take one for the town that has nothing fun left to do in it.
Your comments might be considered if you weren't just being rude and attacking others
Post a Comment