Setting the Record Straight: A Fact-Based Look at Shoreline Proposition 1

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Aquatic Center Design

Setting the Record Straight: A Fact-Based Look at Shoreline Proposition 1

By the Prop 1 – Pro Statement Writers
- Krishnakant Nammi - Susie McDowell - Buddy Smith

Calling Shoreline’s Proposition 1 a “luxury pool” makes for a provocative headline, but it obscures the real question before voters: Does a growing city of more than 60,000 residents believe a public pool is basic community infrastructure worthy of investment?

Our community has spent years investigating how to replace our municipal pool that closed in 2020. The proposed facility will include an eight-lane lap pool, recreation pool, warm hydrotherapy pool, diving area, universal changing rooms, classrooms, and community spaces.

These are not “luxury” amenities. They support swim lessons, water safety, school and community athletics, exercise, rehabilitation, senior fitness, and programming for residents with different physical abilities.

To ensure everyone can make an informed decision on the upcoming ballot, let's look at the real facts behind the concerns raised.

Are there "significant risks" with this project?

The Fact: The City never stated that there are significant risks with this project. A review of project details on the Shoreline City Council Staff Report for Action on Resolution No. 562 reveals the financial plan is transparent, structurally sound, and operating costs are clearly built into the proposal from the start. 

Page 8b-1 explicitly states, “revenues generated by the MPD and pool facility user fees are anticipated to cover all expenses related to constructing and operating the pool facility.” Page 8b-6 discusses the 66% operational cost-recovery model designed to keep the pool accessible and affordable for Shoreline residents.

Public infrastructure like roads, libraries, and parks costs money to operate. Prop 1 would create a Metropolitan Park District (MPD) structured to provide ongoing funding for the construction, operation, and maintenance of the pool. This is a fiscally responsible way to fund the pool long-term. 

Typical of a public pool facility, user fees and other facility revenues will cover approximately 66% of the operating and maintenance costs. These facts mean that taxpayers aren’t writing a blank check; rather, the people who use the pool are contributing a significant portion of the operating costs.

Could interest rates on bonds force the cost of servicing the bonds, and thereby tax rates, to “increase dramatically”?

The Fact: The tax rate has a strict legal cap. By Washington state law, an MPD cannot charge more than $0.75 per $1,000 of assessed property value. The City expects the initial property tax rate to be $0.55 per $1,000. While the exact starting rate depends on market conditions when bonds are sold in late 2027, it cannot legally cross that $0.75 line. Just like a fixed rate mortgage, once the bonds are sold, the interest rate for the city can never increase. You can read the details on Slide #3 of the city’s official legislative presentation for Shoreline Resolution No. 562. Best of all, the board setting this tax rate is our elected City Council, who answer directly to voters during every single election.

Does the measure add 33% to city property taxes and increase total property taxes by approximately 5.5% to 7.5%?

The Fact: Your city tax is only a small fraction of your total property tax bill, which also includes schools, county services, and EMS. When you look at your total overall property tax bill, the pool adds a 5.5% overall increase. For a median Shoreline home, this works out to about $35 a month. You can see exactly where your tax dollars go by typing your address into the online King County Assessor Property Viewer. 33% is an alarmist number that is calculated based on the increase in the city’s share of the overall tax bill.

The cost of waiting is higher than the cost of building. Some people question whether now is the “right time.” The right time was years ago. Every year we wait, construction costs rise, another cohort of kids grows up without nearby swim lessons, and Shoreline residents have to leave our city to swim.

Can the city address its projected deficits, fund essential obligations (including sidewalks, public safety, and existing park measures), and successfully raise taxes further to pay for future public school projects?

The Fact: The City of Shoreline and Municipal Parks District (MPD) will be completely separate financial entities. City budget shortfalls are a separate, state-wide structural issue. State law caps regular city property tax revenue increases at 1% per year, but the cost of running a city rises much faster with inflation. Because of this, Shoreline faces general operating deficits starting as early as 2028 when the current general levy lid lift expires. This challenge faces almost every city in our state, and the City Council will likely ask voters for a routine levy lid lift renewal in 2028 to fix it. The pool project has its own dedicated, voter-approved funding source via the MPD and will not affect or be affected by the city's general operating budget.

With the project at only approximately 10% designed, is the cost estimate sufficiently reliable?

The Fact: "Only 10% designed" is exactly how responsible public projects work. No city spends millions of taxpayer dollars fully designing a building before voters have decided whether to fund it. Early stage estimates are standard practice for ballot measures, and Shoreline’s pool estimates are built on the highest-quality data currently available. If high inflation or changing construction costs do hit the project, the city has immediate safety valves in place. The MPD can modify the building design, adjust user fees, or implement operational cost-cutting measures to keep the budget strictly balanced.

Will vulnerable seniors and people with disabilities get no tax relief?

The Fact: Relief is built in for those who qualify for county relief programs. While state law does not allow an automatic deduction on this specific type of voter-approved tax, protection exists for low-income seniors and disabled residents who already have their property values frozen by the county. If your home's value is frozen, your pool tax will be calculated using that lower, frozen value and not today's higher market prices.

Seniors and people with disabilities rely on warm water pools for low-impact exercise and therapy, and this proposed pool is intentionally designed for that accessibility.

Should we just use nearby pools instead?

The Fact: “Use the neighbor’s pools” isn’t a plan. Neighboring pools are already completely full. Relying on other cities to serve Shoreline’s 60,000 residents is not a realistic strategy. Pools in Edmonds, Lynnwood, and Mountlake Terrace are aging and crowded, and their swim lesson slots fill up within minutes during online registration for Shoreline residents. Our local high school swim teams currently have no public pool in Shoreline to practice in. Shoreline children who don’t have the resources for private clubs have no place to learn how to swim, putting them at higher risk of drowning in Washington’s plentiful natural waters. Let's build an easily accessible public pool where all of our children can learn to thrive.

Were public-private partnerships fully explored?

The Fact: Yes. The idea of a regional or private partnership isn't new. In 2023, Shoreline joined a North King County regional aquatic feasibility study to look at building a joint facility with neighboring jurisdictions. Unsurprisingly, every city wanted the pool built in their own backyard, and a regional agreement could not be reached. The city has studied this for years, and Proposition 1 is the direct result of that work. Additionally, this local project is eligible for a $5 million grant from the King County Parks Levy.

Choosing the Community We Want to Be

Prop 1 is fundamentally about what kind of community Shoreline wants to be. Take a moment and think about the city we want to leave to our children and grandchildren.

In 1968, local voters passed a Forward Thrust bond measure that built 17 public pools across our region, including Shoreline's original municipal pool. That single investment gave our community a shared place for swim lessons, exercise, and family memories for nearly 50 years. Now, it is our turn to build a legacy for the next generation.

On November 3rd, we urge you to join your neighbors in voting yes on Proposition 1. This is a long term investment in swim safety, senior fitness, rehabilitation, recreation and community infrastructure. Shoreline has waited long enough. Let Shoreline Swim! Learn more: https://letshorelineswim.org/


4 comments:

Anonymous,  October 7, 2026 at 4:44 AM  

Honestly, the type of community I would like to see is the one we are destroying around the light rail. Remove trees and install condos. Which brings up another point, with all these new residences and property taxes collected shouldn't there be a surplus of revenue?

Don Wittenberger,  October 19, 2026 at 6:59 PM  

It's the costs that have me knitting my brow. According to my online research, the Federal Way Aquatic Center (which has a 25-yard, 6-lane lap pool and a leisure pool in an 80,000 square feet facility) was built in 1990 for $18.8 million, with $8.8 million provided by King County and $5 million by the Goodwill Games Committee, on land donated by Weyerhaeuser Corp. (Source: Wikipedia)

The Dale Turner YMCA (which has a 25-yard pool in a 52,000 square feet facility) was built in 2008 for $19.5 million from private donations. (Sources given as Daily Herald and YMCA)

Shoreline has budgeted $100 million for a 25-yard, 6-lane lap pool and leisure pool in a 48,000 square feet facility, of which $95 million would be funded by a 20-year bond and $5 million by a King County grant.

All these facilities (existing and proposed) are very similar in pool and building size. Inflation alone doesn't seem to explain the huge disparity in costs; Federal Way and Turner YMCA both were built for under $20 million, yet Shoreline is proposing to spend 5 times that much for a nearly identical pool facility.

The staff report breaks down costs as $16.6 million for land, $22.2 million for design, permits, and other "soft" costs, and $61.2 million for construction. By way of explanation, City of Shoreline purchased the land in 2017 with an interest-only loan from US Bank, so the entire principal of that loan is still due.

The staff report estimates debt service on a 20-year $95 million bond at $7.25 million a year. That appears to assume an interest rate of around 4.55%.

It should be noted that the estimated tax bill of $421 a year for a median-value Shoreline home ($831,000 assessed value) -- this figure is from the staff report -- is based on a tax rate of $0.55 per $1,000, but if Prop. 1 is approved the tax rate could be anywhere from $0.5069 to $0.75; the $431 figure is based on $0.5069. At $0.75, the cap imposed by state law, that would rise to $623 a year. So the $431 given in the voters pamphlet is the minimum the owner of that median-value home could expect to pay.

This bond issue includes only the pool facility. Any future recreational facilities built on the property would come at additional cost, and presumably additional taxes.

What gives me pause is the huge disparity in costs between Shoreline's proposed pool facility and the existing Federal Way and YMCA facilities, even after allowing for 36 years and 18 years of inflation, respectively.

Anonymous,  October 21, 2026 at 9:15 AM  

Yes, I agree with Don. I love the idea, I want to pay for city amenities like this. But it seems excessively expensive for just a pool. Is the water imported?

The argument that the MPD is a separate financial entity doesn’t fix the fact that I would rather pay $35/month towards all those rising city-running costs or for a wider variety of city amenities beyond just a pool.

I realize costs are only going to go up if we don’t vote this in, but that just inspires disappointment that, with time of the essence, this is the estimate proposed. What are my best hopes here? This passes and it’s not as expensive as you thought, but I’m still paying the same amount that can only go towards this overfunded pool? This doesn’t pass and we get a new proposal next election that’s somehow 1/3 of the cost?

I want to vote this in. Maybe I need to do more research. How much were operating costs of the old city pool? Do you have a ballpark for how much a day use pass would be for residents? How many quotes did you get, what was the range, how did we get to $83.4 million for design and construction?? I don’t want to insult your due diligence but I’m just totally incredulous at the numbers. We’ll see what the voters say I guess, but I’m still stuck with how to vote…

Also what a joke of an opposition statement. I wish Don had written it.

Don Wittenberger,  October 24, 2026 at 9:50 PM  

A subtle feature of Prop. 1 that I initially missed is the 20-year financing. Why so short? If a pool's useful life is 40 to 50 years, why does it have to be paid off in 20 years? A 30 or 40-year bond would lower the tax bill by 20% to 30%, everything else staying the same, according to my amortization calculator. Opting for the 20-year bond means current Shoreline homeowners will pay higher taxes to give future Shoreline homeowners a paid-off pool facility; think of that as a gift from today's residents to Shoreline's future residents.

I'm not against a pool. I've lived in Shoreline for 36 years, and until now I've unfailingly voted for school levies and bonds for parks and other amenities. But this proposal is deficient in so many ways. If Prop. 1 fails, the city shouldn't give up on a pool. There is room in existing proposal to cut costs. Reduce the lap pool from 8 lanes to 6, eliminate the lazy river and sauna, and so on. The amortization period should be longer, ideally coinciding with the expected life of the facility, to lower the tax burden. The city planners can do better, and we should give them the opportunity to do better by sending Prop. 1 back to the drawing board again.

Post a Comment

We encourage the thoughtful sharing of information and ideas. We expect comments to be civil and respectful, with no personal attacks or offensive language. We reserve the right to delete any comment.

ShorelineAreaNews.com
Facebook: Shoreline Area News
Twitter: @ShorelineArea
Daily Email edition (don't forget to respond to the Follow.it email)

  © Blogger template The Professional Template II by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP